Heliospectra: Mixed outlook

Research Update

2023-08-29

07:00

Redeye provides an update following Heliospectra’s Q2’23 report. We find the margin improvements, combined with a stronger-than-expected top line, to be encouraging. However, order intake fell short of our expectations, implying a weaker Dutch market and a mixed outlook in the near term. We have made a few minor changes to our near-term estimates. Our fair value range, however, remains unchanged, with a base case of SEK1.9 per share.

JG

HA

Jessica Grunewald

Henrik Alveskog

Contents

Investment thesis

Q2 2023 Review

Financial Q2 2023: Sales and order book

Financial Q2 2023: Profitability and Cost Base

Outlook

Forecast and forecast adjustments

Valuation

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article

Solid sales and margin improvements

Net sales for Q2’23 reached SEK10.1m, reflecting a significant y/y increase and surpassing our estimate by 31%. The gross margin of 44% exceeded our projected 35%. Ongoing price negotiations led to reduced production costs and, in combination with a favourable product mix, resulted in an enhancement of the gross margin. During the second quarter, OPEX amounted to SEK9.4m, marking an approximately 3% y/y decrease and coming in 5% lower than our initial estimate. EBIT was negative SEK4.6m, in contrast to our projection of -SEK 6.8 million. This deviation stemmed from a stronger top line and higher gross margin than anticipated.

Soft order intake

The order intake during the quarter was SEK9.5m in comparison to our estimate of SEK12m. The CEO cited several factors, such as inflation, increased interest rates, reduced energy expenses, and a delayed subsidising program in the Netherlands, as reasons for the order intake being weaker than anticipated. As a result, numerous cultivators delayed their investment decisions to the third quarter, leading to fewer potential projects and escalated competition within the market. We expect the subsidy program to open in September in the Netherlands, which should boost order intake for late ’23 and ’24. Nevertheless, according to the company, the Dutch market has seen a substantial decline of 40% to 50% compared to the previous year. We expect this trend to persist in the near term, leading to ongoing pricing pressures driven by tough competition. Meanwhile, the North American market, particularly Canada, appears more resilient than the Dutch market.

Minor estimate adjustments - Intact fair value range

We have made minor changes to our estimates, mainly affecting ’23, where we lowered sales slightly and trimmed OPEX. The forecast adjustments do not result in any changes in our fair value range. Our Base case is SEK1.9 per share (Bull: SEK5: Bear: SEK0.5). Heliospectra is currently trading at an EV/SALES 1.2x based on our 2024e.

Key financials

SEKm202120222023e2024e
Revenues35.225.741.7100.0
Revenue Growth-8.9%-26.9%62.1%140%
EBITDA-39.1-32.0-17.8-1.5
EBIT-60.2-36.0-21.1-5.5
EBIT Margin-171%-140%-50.6%-5.5%
Net Income-60.2-36.1-21.1-5.5
EV/Revenue2.44.52.61.2

Investment thesis

Case

Unique offering in expanding market

Heliospectra is in the process of repositioning itself from being mainly a supplier of LED lights to greenhouses to a system supplier within data-driven smart farming. 2022 was a transitional year for Heliospectra, dedicated to product development, cost-savings initiatives, and restructuring to become more robust in 2023 with best-in-class product offerings for Smart Farming. With their new product offering consisting of SMART lighting and MITRA LED lights, Heliospectra claims that they both can save up to 30% energy compared to regular LED lights and, in addition, optimize photosynthesis leading to better crops. We believe this implies an opportunity to go from a competitive cost-plus business to a very attractive value proposition that can enable high profitability if successful. As Heliospectra will be the first actor on the market to supply a smart LED solution, we expect they can target and gain larger volume orders than previously. Heliospectra’s new offering includes unique features that allow growers to monitor and control crops down to the square meter, offering the unique potential to improve yields and reduce waste. The relevant market segment is valued to cUSD7b, expected to show double-digit annual growth over the next few years. We believe Heliospectra is in a favorable position to leverage on these strong market trends.

Evidence

First Smart LED Light Solution Order

This first commercial order for the smart LED solution came in November 2022 from an undisclosed customer in the Northeast of the US. The customer provides farmers with innovative solutions for crop growth, pests, and disease protection. We believe this is an order from the new distribution/partner network recently announced by Heliospectra. The order value of USD795,000 is quite significant for Heliospectra, which was delivered in H1'23 2023. We anticipate several orders being announced over the next year, validating that the company is on the right track.

Challenge

Limited commercial progress so far and instability in the European AgHort market

Historically, Heliospectra has been rather optimistic about market conditions and business opportunities, but commercial progress has overall been disappointing. Admittedly, it now has new management, which could turn things around. The company has a strong heritage in plant research and is renowned for its innovations. But the commercial track record needs to be more convincing. In addition, the current energy crisis negatively affects the European AgHort market as many companies are struggling financially and postponing investments.

Challenge

Instability in the European AgHort market

The current energy crisis negatively affects the European AgHort market as many companies struggle financially and might postpone investments. However, the same scenario can prove beneficial for Heliospectra. Thus, growers will likely switch directly to 100% LED lights instead of choosing a more traditional hybrid solution.

Valuation

Wide range

Our fair value range is quite wide: SEK0.5-5.0 per share, with a base case at SEK1.9 per share. However, this wide range is quite common for companies similar to Heliospectra. That is to say, high future growth expectations, a need for additional growth capital until Break-even, and a difficult-to-assess sustainable profitability level. Our Base case scenario assumes break-even in 2025, 21% CAGR 2026-31, and sustainable EBIT margin around 13%.

Q2 2023 Review

The Q2 2023 report came in stronger on all lines compared to our estimates, except for the order intake. Sales, COGS, OPEX and EBIT all came in better than expected. However, order intake is a crucial indicator of future sales. Further, in our latest reach update, we stated that the order intake for Q2’23 would ultimately indicate the market’s response to the new product offering. The order intake in Q2’23 was clearly below our and management’s expectations, implying a weaker market and a constrained outlook in the near term for the Dutch market.

Heliospectra: Actual vs estimates
Q2'23
(SEKm)Q2'22ActualQ2'23eDiff
Net sales3.310.17.731%
Growth-0.6202%130%
Gross margin0.044%35%
OPEX9.79.49.9-5%
EBIT-10.7-4.7-6.8n.a.
Order intake5.39.512.0-21%
Source: Heliospectra, Redeye Research

Financial Q2 2023: Sales and order book

Net sales of SEK10.1m is an increase of 202% y/y and 31% above our expectations of SEK7.7m. The gross margin of 44% is 9pp above our forecast of 35%. Ongoing price negotiations have reduced production costs and, combined with a favourable product mix, led to gross margin improvement. By negotiating directly with A-brand component suppliers and cutting out the go-betweens, the company’s COGS and gross margin should stabilise as we move forward. However, Heliospectra’s business segment is not a high gross margin segment. We anticipate the gross margin to range from 30-45%, depending on the product mix.

Net sales, light

Source: Redeye Research

The order intake of SEK9.5 m is 21 % below our forecast of SEK12m. The CEO cited several factors, such as inflation, increased interest rates, reduced energy expenses, and a deferred subsidising program in the Netherlands, as reasons for the order intake being weaker than anticipated. According to the company, the market in the Netherlands declined by 40% to 50% compared to the previous year. As a result, numerous cultivators delayed their investment decisions to the third quarter, leading to fewer potential projects and escalated competition within the market.
The trailing twelve-month (TTM) order intake has been positively trending since Q3’22. As mentioned above, we expected to see a strong reinforcement of the positive trend and a significantly higher order intake in Q2’23.

Net sales, light

Source: Redeye Research

Financial Q2 2023: Profitability and Cost Base

During the second quarter, OPEX totalled SEK9.4m, marking an approximately 3% y/y decrease and coming in 5% lower than our initial estimate. Last year, Heliospectra initiated a cost-reduction program. However, the program was introduced in Q1’22, implying that Heliospectra still managed to cut some further costs y/y. The program has consistently yielded positive results during the last five quarters, effectively shaping the company’s cost base.
EBIT was reported as negative SEK4.6m, in contrast to our projection of -SEK 6.8 million. This deviation mainly stemmed from a stronger top line and lower COGS than anticipated.
At the end of the second quarter, the cash position was SEK16m, and the net cash flow after financing activities was SEK2.7m. The net cash flow includes issue proceeds of SEK21.5m from the rights issue in April ‘23.

Outlook

The Dutch market holds substantial significance for Heliospectra, given its scale and prominence in the horticulture industry. Inflation, increased interest rates, reduced energy expenses, and a deferred subsidising program in the Netherlands affect the market in the Netherlands, which declined from -40% to -50% y/y. As a result, numerous cultivators delayed their investment decisions to the third quarter. Further, Heliospectra’s ability to finalise orders has encountered obstacles due to an absence of reference projects. Growers frequently lean towards more established suppliers. To tackle this challenge, sales and marketing tactics are now concentrated on augmenting brand recognition within the Netherlands and establishing reference growers within both the ornamental and vegetable sectors. Heliospectra is preparing to expand the sales and application team in Western Europe to support these initiatives, anchored by a strategic hub in the Netherlands. We believe a legal entity and sales office will be in place during H1’24.
The North American market, particularly Canada, appears more resilient than the Dutch market. Heliospectra is encountering comparatively less competition in this region, and the existing subsidy programs enable substantial price reductions for the end customers.
Overall, the outlook is cautiously optimistic. The focus is clearly on establishing a footprint in the critical Duch market and on the European market, whereas the North American offers greater potential for securing larger volume orders in the immediate future. Meanwhile, the R&D activity remains high, with several product and platform enhancements ahead that could potentially boost order intake.

Forecast and forecast adjustments

Our forecast still implies that Heliospectra will reach breakeven in 2025. Following the Q2’23 report, we trimmed our forecast for H2’23, lowering our topline expectations by 17%. On the bright side, we have taken down OPEX, positively affecting EBIT for ’23. We believe Heliospectra currently has significant pending contracts that can potentially materialise into confirmed orders in the fourth quarter. However, it is important to note that these contracts have not been factored into our existing forecasts. Should these contracts indeed translate into orders, there is also the possibility that their fulfilment could extend into the first half of 2024.
Considering the seasonality of the business, with a weaker H1 followed by a substantially stronger H2, we expect to see quarterly breakeven results prior to 2025. Nevertheless, we estimate Heliospectra will achieve full-year breakeven in 2025. The tables below summarise our forecast changes and forecast ’23e-‘25e.

Heliospectra: Estimate change
(SEKm)2023E2024e2025e
Net sales
Old50100149
New42100150
% change-17%0%0%
EBIT
Old-23-98
margin-46%-9%6%
New-21-610
margin-42%-6%7%
% change10%38%18%
Source: Redeye Research
Heliospectra: Estimate (mSEK)
(SEKm)20222023Q12023Q22023Q3e2023Q4e2023e2024e2025e
Net Sales26710121342100150
Gross Profit62445164060
Opex-47-9-9-9-10-38-46-49
EBITDA-32-6-4-4-4-18-214
EBIT-36-6-5-5-5-21-610
Growth (%)-27%26%201%70%30%62%140%50%
Gross margin23%35%44%36%36%38%40%40%
EBITDA margin (%)-124%-81%-40%-36%-30%-43%-2%10%
EBIT margin (%)-140%-92%-47%-43%-37%-51%-6%7%
Net income margin (%)-140%-92%-47%-43%-37%-51%-6%7%
Source: Redeye Research

Valuation

Our valuation remains intact, with a Base case fair value of around SEK 1.9 per share. This is based on the financial forecasts in the table above and long-term assumptions outlined in the table below, including:
• Our valuation includes the dilution from the equity issue in April ’23.
• Our fair value range remains quite broad: SEK0.5-5 per share. However, this is quite common for companies similar to Heliospectra. That is to say, high future growth expectations and a difficult-to-assess sustainable profitability level.

Heliospectra: Base case scenario
Assumptions:2028-32eDCF-value
CAGR Sales17%WACC13%
EBIT margin (avg)16%PV FCF 2023-203766
2033-37ePV of Terminal Value159
CAGR Sales5%Sum PV225
EBIT margin (avg)16%Net cash 2023e3
TerminalDCF-value228
Net sales, 2036, SEKm718Fair value per share (diluted)1.9
Growth FCF, 2036 =>2%Share price today0.9
EBIT margin, 2036 =>15%Potential:100%
Source: Redeye Research

Quality Rating

People: 2

The management team has been subject to a reorganization in 2022 under the leadership of the interim CEO, Bonny Heeren. As management history is limited, it holds back the overall People score. However, Bonny Heeren has an excellent background with deep market insights and connections, adding to the score. The degree of innovation and the proactive mindset are also positive factors in the score.

Business: 3

Heliospectra has expanded into new geographies with an asset-light business model that includes embedded optionality. Long-term tailwinds support the company's operations, and its offering meets a genuine customer need. Exemplifications of why the score is held back; lack of pricing power, market share, a low-margin business, and the absence of a significant portion of recurring revenues.

Financials: 1

Redeye’s financial rating model is determined using historical figures and requires consistent positive earnings. Heliospectra is yet to become profitable, substantially affecting its financial rating. On the optimistic side, we are more than likely to revisit the rating and expect this score to increase as more historical data builds up and the company turns losses into profits.

Financials

Income statement
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Revenues25.741.7100.0150.0
Cost of Revenue19.825.960.090.0
Operating Expenses37.933.641.545.5
EBITDA-32.0-17.8-1.514.5
Depreciation0.300.000.000.00
Amortizations3.73.34.04.5
EBIT-36.0-21.1-5.510.0
Shares in Associates0.000.000.000.00
Interest Expenses0.000.000.000.00
Net Financial Items-0.140.000.000.00
EBT-36.1-21.1-5.510.0
Income Tax Expenses0.000.000.000.00
Net Income-36.1-21.1-5.510.0
Balance sheet
Assets
Non-current assets
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Property, Plant and Equipment (Net)0.410.410.410.41
Goodwill0.000.000.000.00
Intangible Assets18.719.425.437.4
Right-of-Use Assets0.000.000.000.00
Other Non-Current Assets0.200.200.200.20
Total Non-Current Assets19.320.026.038.0
Current assets
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Inventories8.914.625.015.0
Accounts Receivable2.612.530.045.0
Other Current Assets8.20.000.0012.0
Cash Equivalents12.813.81.42.9
Total Current Assets32.440.956.474.9
Total Assets51.860.982.4112.9
Equity and Liabilities
Equity
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Non Controlling Interest0.000.000.000.00
Shareholder's Equity12.813.27.717.7
Non-current liabilities
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Long Term Debt9.09.09.09.0
Long Term Lease Liabilities0.000.000.000.00
Other Non-Current Lease Liabilities8.88.88.88.8
Total Non-Current Liabilities17.817.817.817.8
Current liabilities
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Short Term Debt0.000.000.000.00
Short Term Lease Liabilities0.000.000.000.00
Accounts Payable8.98.315.018.0
Other Current Liabilities12.221.541.959.4
Total Current Liabilities21.129.856.977.4
Total Liabilities and Equity51.860.882.4112.9
Cash flow
SEKm20222023e2024e2025e
Operating Cash Flow-33.3-15.8-2.418.0
Investing Cash Flow-6.0-4.7-10.0-16.5
Financing Cash Flow42.621.50.000.00

Rating definitions

The team

Disclosures and disclaimers

Premium Plan required to unlock

Unlock companies to access

more high quality research.

Contents

Investment thesis

Q2 2023 Review

Financial Q2 2023: Sales and order book

Financial Q2 2023: Profitability and Cost Base

Outlook

Forecast and forecast adjustments

Valuation

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article