Heliospectra: Convincing order intake validates product-market fit.

Research Update

2024-05-07

07:11

Analyst Q&A

Closed

Jessica Grunewald answered 3 questions.

Redeye maintains its optimistic outlook post the Q1 2024 report despite slightly lower sales and profitability than expected. The surprisingly strong order intake confirms product-market fit and increases the likelihood of significant orders from the European market. Our Base case remains intact at SEK1.4, with considerable upside potential in the share price highlighted.

JG

HA

Jessica Grunewald

Henrik Alveskog

Contents

Q1 2024 Review

Financial Q1 2023: Sales and order book

Financial Q1 2024: Profitability, Cost Base and Cashflow

Outlook

Forecast and forecast adjustments

Valuation

Investment thesis

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article

Q1: Slightly weaker topline and profitably  

Heliospectra reported a 2% growth rate y/y, resulting in net sales of SEK7.2m, below our expectations of SEK8.4m, resulting in a -15 % deviation. OPEX amounted to SEK9.4m, flat y/y and above our SEK7.8m estimate. Due to a slightly lower topline and higher OPEX than forecasted, the operating loss (EBIT) was higher than expected at SEK6.6 vs our -SEK4m estimate. Overall, a slightly weaker performance than our forecast.

Robust order intake reinforces confidence in short-term projections

The highlight of the report was the exceptionally strong order intake at SEK27m (almost the same amount as the total order intake during 2023), c70% above our forecast of SEK16m. A substantial contributing factor to the increased order intake is a positive trend with larger orders from the Canadian market. During the quarter, Heliospectra announced two larger orders from Canadian customers, totalling SEK15.5m. The delivery of these orders is spread out through H2 2024 and 2025. We have already factored in a strong H2 2024, and the strong order intake in Q1 2024 reinforces confidence in our estimates. For 2024e, we factor in a 65% y/y sales growth, equal to SEK58m. Additionally, we believe the strong order intake enhances the prospects for breakthrough orders from the crucial European market.

Intact Base case at SEK1.4 per share

On the back of the Q4 2023 report, we have made minimal adjustments to our estimates, primarily impacting 2024e by increasing our sales estimates by 2% and our OPEX estimates by c13%. Our adjustments leave our fair value range intact at SEK0.4-SEK3.6 per share with a Base case of SEK1.4. Heliospectra is currently trading at an EV/Sales multiple of 1x based on 2024e and EV/EBITDA 7.4x on 2025e, and we highlight a considerable upside potential in the share price.

Key financials

SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Revenues34.738.761.691.5135.2
Revenue Growth-27.5%11.5%59.2%48.4%47.8%
EBITDA-32.0-19.8-8.78.418.4
EBIT-36.0-23.7-11.91.411.9
EBIT Margin-140%-67.1%-20.5%1.6%9.0%
Net Income-36.1-22.7-11.91.411.9
EV/Sales4.42.11.10.70.4
EV/EBIT-3.2-3.1-5.544.84.5

Q1 2024 Review

The report showed a slightly weaker net sales and profitability than expected but a significant uptick in order intake. We interpret the Q1 2024 report as a transitional quarter, anticipating stronger quarters ahead in 2024 due to the robust order intake during the quarter and the positive outlook. The cost base was slightly higher than expected due to the office relocation during the quarter. However, we expect a reduction in costs following the completion of the move to a cheaper office. The cash position at the end of the quarter (SEK4.8m) and a negative working capital of approximately SEK6m raises concerns. However, the report indicates that “with the increased order intake and our payment terms of 80-100% in advance, we will see a positive cash flow in coming period”.

Heliospectra: Actual vs estimates
(SEKm)Q1 2023Q1 2024aQ1 2024eDiff
Net sales7.07.28.4-15%
Growth y/y26%2%20%-18pp
Gross margin35%40%43%-3pp
OPEX9.59.47.821%
EBIT-6.5-6.6-4.0n.a.
Order intake1.627.016.069%
Source: Heliospectra, Redeye Research

Financial Q1 2023: Sales and order book

Heliospectra reported a y/y growth rate of 2%, resulting in net sales of SEK7.2m, which fell below our expectations of SEK8.4m, representing a -15% deviation. The gross margin of 40% was 3pp below our forecast of 43%. Although the report did not disclose the product mix between Agtech and the greenhouse segment, given the gross margin of 40%, we anticipated that a significant portion of the sales came from the Agtech segment, which typically holds a higher gross margin than the greenhouse segment.

Net sales, light

Order intake was exceptionally strong at SEK27m (almost the same amount as the total order intake during 2023), c70% above our forecast of SEK16m. A substantial contributing factor to the increased order intake is a positive trend with larger orders from the Canadian market. During the quarter, Heliospectra announced two larger orders from Canadian customers, totalling SEK15.5m. The delivery of these orders is spread out through H2 2024 and 2025. The report indicates that larger order values from the Agtech segment further enhanced the order book intake during the quarter.

Order, light

Financial Q1 2024: Profitability, Cost Base and Cashflow

OPEX amounted to SEK9.4m, flat y/y and above our SEK7.8m estimate. The cost base was slightly higher than expected due to the office relocation during the quarter. We anticipate a reduction in costs following the completion of the move to a cheaper office. However, the new office in the Netherlands and new sales staff might offset the cost savings in our view. Due to a somewhat lower topline and higher OPEX than forecasted, the operating loss (EBIT) was higher than expected at SEK6.6 vs our -SEK4m estimate.

OPEX,light

Operating cash flow for the quarter was -SEK3.5m; by the end of the quarter, cash and cash equivalents amounted to cSEK4.7m. In November 2023, Heliospectra announced a secured bridge loan of SEK10m from the main owners Weland Stål AB, Agartha AB, and Corespring New Technology AB. The cash position at the quarter's end and a negative working capital of approximately SEK6m raise concerns. However, the report indicates that “With the increased order intake, and our 80-100 percent prepayment conditions, we will see a positive cash flow in coming period”.
It is worth highlighting that the board of Heliospectra has chosen to create a control balance sheet for the company, subject to review by the company's auditor. We await the outcome, but we find it very likely that the main owners will continue to support Heliospectra should a capital injection be needed.

Outlook

Having dedicated 2023 to updating the product and service platform, we view 2024 as the commercialization year for Heliospectra. Several supporting indicators support this reasoning:

  1. The new modular LED lighting platform enables Heliospectra to cater to various environments and crops. The updated control system, helioCORE™, enhances reliability and accuracy in algorithms by integrating real weather forecasts, energy prices, and LED lamp efficiency. Additionally, Heliospectra introduced additional sensors. They can now provide growers with market-leading quality and control of the light environment at a highly competitive cost per mmol (the cost per unit of light intensity provided by the LED lighting system). At the same time, its customers can save up to 35% on their energy consumption.
  2. The Energy crises in Europe have faded out, leaving a contained investment need for the greenhouse segment.
  3. The subsidy program in the Netherlands is now open for applications, and growers have up to two years after approval to reimburse the 20% discount on energy-saving investments.
  4. The surprisingly strong order intake from the North American market validates product-market fit. In our view, it enhances the prospects for breakthrough orders from the important European market. Larger orders from the European market would confirm a turnaround in our view. Further, orders from the important Duch market within the greenhouse segment would give Helisospectra a much-needed reference case to penetrate the market further.

Conversely, electricity availability for growers presents a similar challenge in both the European and North American markets. Growers are grappling with either insufficient electricity supply or delays in grid connections, potentially prolonging investment decisions for new greenhouses.

Further, this quote from the Financial Comment section within the Q1 2024 report is worth noting: "With the positive trend, the board is evaluating complementary alternative financing possibilities for strategic investments." We presume this relates to potential partnerships which is probably a sound strategy for a small company like Heliospectra. We very much look forward to more info, as discussions unfold.

Forecast and forecast adjustments

Our forecast still implies that Heliospectra will reach breakeven in 2025. Considering the seasonality of the business, with a weaker H1 followed by a substantially stronger H2, we expect to see quarterly breakeven results before 2025. Nevertheless, we estimate Heliospectra will achieve full-year breakeven in 2025. On the back of the Q1 2024 report, we have made minimal adjustments to our estimates, primarily impacting 2024e by increasing our sales estimates by 2% and our OPEX estimates by c13%. Our OPEX estimate now includes costs for the new office in the Netherlands and new sales staff. We have already factored in a strong H2 2024, and the solid order intake in Q1 2024 reinforces confidence in our estimates. 

Heliospectra: Estimate changes
(SEKm)2024e2025e2026e
Net sales
Old5785128
New5887131
% change2%2%2%
EBIT
Old-5112
margin-18%-1%4%
New-12112
margin-21%2%9%
Source: Redeye Research
Heliospectra: Estimate
(SEKm)20232024Q1a2024Q2e2024Q3e2024Q4e2024e2025e2026e
Net Sales3571118225887131
Gross Profit133589253858
Opex-37-9-8-9-10-37-33-43
EBITDA-32-6-2-10-9818
EBIT-24-7-3-2-1-12112
Sales Growth (%)37%2%10%120%120%65%50%50%
Gross margin38%41%43%43%43%43%43%44%
EBITDA margin (%)-91%-82%-18%-4%1%-15%10%14%
EBIT margin (%)-67%-91%-25%-9%-3%-20%2%9%
Net income margin (%)-64%-91%-25%-9%-3%-20%2%9%
Source: Redeye Research

Valuation

On the back of the Q1 2024 report, we have made minimal adjustments to our estimates, primarily impacting 2024e by increasing our sales estimates by 2% and our OPEX estimates by c13%. Our adjustments leave our fair value range intact at SEK0.4-SEK3.6 per share, and our Bace case is SEK1.4. Heliospectra is currently trading at an EV/Sales multiple of 1x based on 2024e and EV/EBITDA 7.4x on 2025e, and we highlight a considerable upside potential in the share price. Our Base case valuation is based on the long-term assumptions in the table below.

Additionally, we foresee a high likelihood of the bridge loan, obtained in November 2023, being settled through a directed share issuance rather than a cash repayment. Consequently, our valuation includes the anticipated dilution.

Heliospectra: Base case scenario
Assumptions:2027-33eDCF-value
CAGR Sales18%WACC13.5%
EBIT margin (avg)12%PV FCF 2024-2038106
2034-38ePV of Terminal Value87
CAGR Sales4%Sum PV192
EBIT margin (avg)16%Net cash 6
TerminalDCF-value198
Net sales, 2038, SEKm473Fair value per share (diluted)1.4
Growth FCF, 2038 =>2%Share price today0.4
EBIT margin, 2038 =>15%Potential:213%
Source: Redeye Research

Investment thesis

Case

Unique offering in expanding market

Heliospectra is in the process of repositioning itself from being mainly a supplier of LED lights to greenhouses to a system supplier within data-driven smart farming. 2022 and 2023 were transitional years for Helicpectra, which were dedicated to product development, cost-savings initiatives, and restructuring to become more robust in 2024 with best-in-class product offerings for Smart Farming. With their new product offering consisting of SMART lighting and MITRA LED lights, Heliospectra claims that they both can save up to 14% energy compared to regular LED lights and, in addition, optimize photosynthesis, leading to better crops. We believe this implies an opportunity to go from a competitive cost-plus business to a very attractive value proposition that can enable high profitability if successful. As Heliospectra will be the first actor on the market to supply a smart LED solution, we expect they can target and gain larger volume orders than previously. Heliospectra’s new offering includes unique features that allow growers to monitor and control crops down to the square meter, offering unprecedented potential to improve yields and reduce waste. The relevant market segment is valued at cUSD7b, expected to show double-digit annual growth over the next few years. We believe Heliospectra is in a good position to leverage these strong market trends.

Evidence

The recent influx of orders validates product-market fit

The initial commercial order for the smart LED solution was secured in November 2022 from an undisclosed client in the Northeastern United States, amounting to cSEK7.8m. In Q1 2024, Heliospectra has received two larger orders from the North American market, totaling SEK15.5m. These recent orders encompass both MITRA X LED lights and the helioCORE system solution, allowing growers to achieve additional savings of up to 35% on top of the energy efficiency gains from transitioning from HPS to LED lighting. This increased efficiency makes North American growers eligible for subsidy programs and should boost order intake further during 2024.

Challenge

Limited commercial progress so far on the European market

Historically, Heliospectra has been rather optimistic about market conditions and business opportunities, but its commercial progress has been disappointing overall. Admittedly, it now has new management, which could turn things around. The company has a strong heritage in plant research and is renowned for its innovations. But the commercial track record must be more convincing on the European market, especially the critical Duch market.

Challenge

Instability in the European AgHort market

The recent energy crisis negatively affects the European AgHort market as many companies struggle financially and might postpone investments. However, the same scenario can prove beneficial for Heliospectra. Thus, growers will likely switch directly to 100% LED lights instead of choosing a more traditional hybrid solution.

Valuation

Wide range

Our fair value range is quite wide: SEK0.4-3.6 per share, with a base case at SEK1.4 per share. However, this wide range is quite common for companies similar to Heliospectra. That is to say, high future growth expectations, a need for additional growth capital until Break-even, and a difficult-to-assess sustainable profitability level. Our Base case scenario assumes break-even in 2025, 21% CAGR 2026-31, and a sustainable EBIT margin of around 15%.

Quality Rating

People: 2

The management team has been subject to a reorganization in 2022 under the leadership of the new CEO, Bonny Heeren. As management history is limited, it holds back the overall People score. However, Bonny Heeren has an excellent background with deep market insights and connections, adding to the score. The degree of innovation and the proactive mindset are also positive factors in the score.

Business: 3

Heliospectra has expanded into new geographies with an asset-light business model that includes embedded optionality. Long-term tailwinds support the company's operations, and its offering meets a genuine customer need. Exemplifications of why the score is held back; lack of pricing power, market share, a low-margin business, and the absence of a significant portion of recurring revenues.

Financials: 1

Redeye’s financial rating model is determined using historical figures and requires consistent positive earnings. Heliospectra is yet to become profitable, substantially affecting its financial rating. On the optimistic side, we are more than likely to revisit the rating and expect this score to increase as more historical data builds up and the company turns losses into profits.

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Disclosures and disclaimers

Premium Plan required to unlock

Unlock companies to access

more high quality research.

Contents

Q1 2024 Review

Financial Q1 2023: Sales and order book

Financial Q1 2024: Profitability, Cost Base and Cashflow

Outlook

Forecast and forecast adjustments

Valuation

Investment thesis

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article